Ambassadeurs : Chigorin, Mikhail (5x), Zukertort, Johannes (4x), White, Max (4x), Lasker, Emanuel (4x), Sinkovics, Peter (4x), Winawer, Szymon (3x), Bird, Henry (3x), Taubenhaus, Jean (3x)
5…a6 — 38.4% (146 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Zapata, Alonso (6x), Fressinet, Laurent (4x), Arencibia Rodriguez, Walter (3x), Kramnik, Vladimir (3x), Showalter, Jackson (2x), Pillsbury, Harry (2x), Etmans, Maarten (2x), Salazar, Adriana (2x)
5…d6 — 8.9% (34 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Bogoljubow, Efim (4x), Leventic, Ivan (3x), Kostic, Boris (2x), Huisl, Wolfgang (2x), Nyholm, Gustav (1x), Harald, C (1x), Barry, John F (1x), Bogoljubov, Efim (1x)
5…Bc5 — 7.9% (30 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Bru Rullo, Llatzer (2x), Warburton, Charles (1x), Clarke, Jaheim (1x), Cleguer, Henri (1x), Nedelcot Pierre (1x), Gil Correja, C. (1x), Zoubida Rachedi F (1x), Koutecky, Vaclav (1x)
Analyse statistique des coups candidats
Répartition par niveau Elo (% des parties)
Tranche Elo
N parties
5…Be7
5…a6
5…d6
5…Bc5
<1800
11
27%
36%
—
36%
1800-2200
70
36%
33%
14%
7%
2200-2600
158
37%
49%
9%
3%
2600+
21
29%
71%
—
—
Évolution par décennie (% des parties)
Décennie
N parties
5…Be7
5…a6
5…d6
5…Bc5
1860s
3
100%
—
—
—
1880s
13
92%
8%
—
—
1890s
13
85%
15%
—
—
1900s
13
92%
—
8%
—
1910s
3
—
—
100%
—
1920s
6
33%
—
67%
—
1930s
2
50%
—
—
50%
1950s
4
100%
—
—
—
1960s
9
56%
33%
11%
—
1970s
4
25%
25%
25%
25%
1980s
21
38%
52%
—
—
1990s
62
37%
32%
13%
11%
2000s
99
44%
33%
6%
13%
2010s
102
25%
58%
6%
8%
2020s
26
19%
62%
15%
—
Tendances récentes (2010s → 2020s)
Coup
2010s
2020s
Δ
5…Be7
25%
19%
▼ -5.3%
5…a6
58%
62%
▲ +3.7%
5…d6
6%
15%
▲ +9.5%
5…Bc5
8%
0%
▼ -7.8%
Joueurs célèbres
Champions du monde dans cette position
Lasker, Emanuel — 4 parties Kramnik, Vladimir — 3 parties Carlsen, Magnus — 2 parties Steinitz, Wilhelm — 1 partie Tal, Mikhail — 1 partie
Parties historiques
5…Be7 — 41.1% (156 parties)
1862 — Bird, Henry vs Anderssen, Adolf — 0-1 — London ENG 1862 — Bird, Henry vs Anderssen, Adolf — 0-1 — London ENG 1866 — Bird, Henry vs Steinitz, Wilhelm — 0-1 — London ENG 1880 — Zukertort, Johannes vs Rosenthal, Samuel — 1/2-1/2 — London ENG 1880 — Zukertort, Johannes vs Rosenthal, Samuel — 1-0 — London ENG
5…a6 — 38.4% (146 parties)
1887 — Blackburne, Joseph vs Zukertort, Johannes — 1/2-1/2 — London ENG 1898 — Showalter, Jackson vs Pillsbury, Harry — 0-1 — New York, NY USA 1898 — Showalter, Jackson vs Pillsbury, Harry — 0-1 — New York, NY USA 1967 — Robatsch, Karl vs Minev, Nikolay N — 1/2-1/2 — Maribor 1967 — Eretova, Kveta vs Mulder, Jeanette — 1-0 — Beverwijk NED
5…d6 — 8.9% (34 parties)
1909 — Phillips, Harold Meyer vs Aadhyeta Roy — 1-0 — New York, NY USA 1914 — Bogoljubov, Efim vs Wainstein, S. — 1/2-1/2 — Baden 1914 — Bogoljubow, Efim vs Vajnstejn, Samuil O — 1/2-1/2 — Baden-Baden GER 1915 — Barry, John F vs Kostic, Boris — 1-0 — Boston, MA USA 1920 — Nyholm, Gustav vs Harald, C — 1-0 — Malmo SWE
5…Bc5 — 7.9% (30 parties)
1938 — Warburton, Charles vs Clarke, Jaheim — 1-0 — cr. 1975 — Cleguer, Henri vs Nedelcot Pierre — 0-1 — ? 1991 — Gil Correja, C. vs Zoubida Rachedi F — 1-0 — Mamaia 1993 — Polgar, Sofia vs Sherzer, Alex — 0-1 — Brno CZE 1997 — Koutecky, Vaclav vs Vacha, Jaroslav — 1-0 — Plzen CZE
Kramnik, Vladimir — 3 parties
Carlsen, Magnus — 2 parties
Steinitz, Wilhelm — 1 partie
Tal, Mikhail — 1 partie
1862 — Bird, Henry vs Anderssen, Adolf — 0-1 — London ENG
1866 — Bird, Henry vs Steinitz, Wilhelm — 0-1 — London ENG
1880 — Zukertort, Johannes vs Rosenthal, Samuel — 1/2-1/2 — London ENG
1880 — Zukertort, Johannes vs Rosenthal, Samuel — 1-0 — London ENG
1898 — Showalter, Jackson vs Pillsbury, Harry — 0-1 — New York, NY USA
1898 — Showalter, Jackson vs Pillsbury, Harry — 0-1 — New York, NY USA
1967 — Robatsch, Karl vs Minev, Nikolay N — 1/2-1/2 — Maribor
1967 — Eretova, Kveta vs Mulder, Jeanette — 1-0 — Beverwijk NED
1914 — Bogoljubov, Efim vs Wainstein, S. — 1/2-1/2 — Baden
1914 — Bogoljubow, Efim vs Vajnstejn, Samuil O — 1/2-1/2 — Baden-Baden GER
1915 — Barry, John F vs Kostic, Boris — 1-0 — Boston, MA USA
1920 — Nyholm, Gustav vs Harald, C — 1-0 — Malmo SWE
1975 — Cleguer, Henri vs Nedelcot Pierre — 0-1 — ?
1991 — Gil Correja, C. vs Zoubida Rachedi F — 1-0 — Mamaia
1993 — Polgar, Sofia vs Sherzer, Alex — 0-1 — Brno CZE
1997 — Koutecky, Vaclav vs Vacha, Jaroslav — 1-0 — Plzen CZE