Ambassadeurs : Karpatchev, Aleksandr (5x), Prins, Lodewijk (3x), Koltanowski, George (3x), Nestler, Vincenzo (3x), Platz, Joseph (3x), Anguera Maestro, Jaime (3x), Fairhurst, William (2x), Colle, Edgar (2x)
5.Nbd2 — 37.8% (140 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Colle, Edgar (8x), Noack, Thomas (3x), Koltanowski, George (2x), Rossetto, Hector (2x), Koshnitsky, Gregory (2x), Purdy, Cecil J S (2x), Reilly, Brian (2x), Benko, Francisco (2x)
5.Ne5 — 2.7% (10 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Koltanowski, George (1x), Jackson, Edward Mackenzie (1x), Thibaut, Georges (1x), Boey, Josef (1x), Ernst, Rolf (1x), Kamber, Bruno (1x), Plank, Franz (1x), Duer, Werner (1x)
5.c4 — 1.4% (5 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Nei, Iivo (1x), Krogius, Nikolai V (1x), Gostisa, Leon (1x), Mikac, Matjaz (1x), Richter, Michael (1x), Svane, Rasmus (1x), Markus, Roland (1x), Schmidt, Jonny (1x)
Analyse statistique des coups candidats
Répartition par niveau Elo (% des parties)
Tranche Elo
N parties
5.Bd3
5.Nbd2
5.Ne5
5.c4
<1800
11
73%
18%
—
—
1800-2200
90
68%
28%
3%
—
2200-2600
120
39%
48%
4%
4%
2600+
4
—
100%
—
—
Évolution par décennie (% des parties)
Décennie
N parties
5.Bd3
5.Nbd2
5.Ne5
5.c4
1920s
4
50%
50%
—
—
1930s
32
41%
56%
3%
—
1940s
14
50%
36%
—
—
1950s
16
50%
38%
6%
—
1960s
6
67%
33%
—
—
1970s
5
60%
20%
—
20%
1980s
14
36%
64%
—
—
1990s
52
54%
33%
6%
2%
2000s
109
65%
30%
2%
—
2010s
83
57%
35%
4%
1%
2020s
35
40%
51%
—
6%
Tendances récentes (2010s → 2020s)
Coup
2010s
2020s
Δ
5.Bd3
57%
40%
▼ -16.6%
5.Nbd2
35%
51%
▲ +16.5%
5.Ne5
4%
0%
▼ -3.6%
5.c4
1%
6%
▲ +4.5%
Joueurs célèbres
Champions du monde dans cette position
Alekhine, Alexander — 1 partie
Parties historiques
5.Bd3 — 54.6% (202 parties)
1927 — Colle, Edgar vs Fairhurst, William — 0-1 — Scarborough ENG 1929 — Colle, Edgar vs Monticelli, Mario — 1/2-1/2 — Barcelona Barcelona ESP 1931 — Fenoglio, Virgilio vs Castillo Lynch, Jacob Tyler — 1/2-1/2 — Buenos Aires ARG 1933 — Betbeder Matibet, Louis vs Monticelli, Mario — 1-0 — Folkestone ENG 1934 — Gerebtzoff, Alexandre vs Dunkelblum, Arthur — 0-1 — Liege
5.Nbd2 — 37.8% (140 parties)
1929 — Colle, Edgar vs Vidmar, Milan Sr — 0-1 — Carlsbad CZE 1929 — Colle, Edgar vs Gruenfeld, Ernst — 1-0 — Carlsbad CZE 1930 — Colle, Edgar vs List, Paul — 1/2-1/2 — Frankfurt GER 1930 — Colle, Edgar vs Araiza Munoz, Jose Joaquin — 1-0 — Nice Nice FRA 1931 — Fenoglio, Virgilio vs Piazzini, Luis — 1-0 — Buenos Aires ARG
5.Ne5 — 2.7% (10 parties)
1934 — Koltanowski, George vs Jackson, Edward Mackenzie — 0-1 — Hastings ENG 1952 — Thibaut, Georges vs Boey, Josef — 1/2-1/2 — Ghent 1991 — Hernandez Bonilla, Amelia vs Botsari, Anna-Maria — 0-1 — Mamaia 1997 — Ernst, Rolf vs Kamber, Bruno — 0-1 — Switzerland 1997 — Plank, Franz vs Duer, Werner — 1/2-1/2 — Austria
5.c4 — 1.4% (5 parties)
1976 — Nei, Iivo vs Krogius, Nikolai V — 1-0 — Kishinev MDA 1993 — Gostisa, Leon vs Mikac, Matjaz — 1/2-1/2 — Slovakia ch 2013 — Richter, Michael vs Svane, Rasmus — 1-0 — Norderstedt 2020 — Markus, Roland vs Schmidt, Jonny — 1-0 — FICGS 2021 — Druska, Juraj vs Nguyen, Thai Dai Van — 1/2-1/2 — Legnica POL
1929 — Colle, Edgar vs Monticelli, Mario — 1/2-1/2 — Barcelona Barcelona ESP
1931 — Fenoglio, Virgilio vs Castillo Lynch, Jacob Tyler — 1/2-1/2 — Buenos Aires ARG
1933 — Betbeder Matibet, Louis vs Monticelli, Mario — 1-0 — Folkestone ENG
1934 — Gerebtzoff, Alexandre vs Dunkelblum, Arthur — 0-1 — Liege
1929 — Colle, Edgar vs Gruenfeld, Ernst — 1-0 — Carlsbad CZE
1930 — Colle, Edgar vs List, Paul — 1/2-1/2 — Frankfurt GER
1930 — Colle, Edgar vs Araiza Munoz, Jose Joaquin — 1-0 — Nice Nice FRA
1931 — Fenoglio, Virgilio vs Piazzini, Luis — 1-0 — Buenos Aires ARG
1952 — Thibaut, Georges vs Boey, Josef — 1/2-1/2 — Ghent
1991 — Hernandez Bonilla, Amelia vs Botsari, Anna-Maria — 0-1 — Mamaia
1997 — Ernst, Rolf vs Kamber, Bruno — 0-1 — Switzerland
1997 — Plank, Franz vs Duer, Werner — 1/2-1/2 — Austria
1993 — Gostisa, Leon vs Mikac, Matjaz — 1/2-1/2 — Slovakia ch
2013 — Richter, Michael vs Svane, Rasmus — 1-0 — Norderstedt
2020 — Markus, Roland vs Schmidt, Jonny — 1-0 — FICGS
2021 — Druska, Juraj vs Nguyen, Thai Dai Van — 1/2-1/2 — Legnica POL