A41w — Modern
1.d4 d6 2.c4 g6 3.Nc3 Bg7 4.Nf3 Bg4 5.e3
Les coups candidats
Ambassadeurs : Suttles, Duncan (12x), Arapovic, Vitomir (11x), Szenetra, Werner (7x), Ivkov, Borislav (6x), Ivanov, Alexander. (6x), Robatsch, Karl (5x), Nogueiras Santiago, Jesus (4x), Carlier, Bruno (4x)
5…Nf6 — 26.3% (449 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Bilek, Istvan (11x), Tkachiev, Vladislav (8x), Mamedyarov, Shakhriyar (8x), Gagunashvili, Merab (8x), Knaak, Rainer (7x), Sanikidze, Tornike (6x), Stocek, Jiri (6x), Petran, Peter (6x)
5…c5 — 20.3% (346 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Onyshchuk, Volodymyr (9x), Jansa, Vlastimil (8x), Vujadinovic, Goran (8x), Davies, Nigel R (7x), Engelbert, Christoph (7x), Kakageldyev, Amanmurad (6x), Losev, Dmitry (5x), Warakomski, Tomasz (5x)
5…Nd7 — 9.5% (162 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Chepukaitis, Genrikh (4x), Freeman, Richard C P (4x), Tseshkovsky, Vitaly (3x), Ree, Hans (2x), Boyd, Stephen (2x), Huebner, Robert (2x), Preiss, Lore (2x), Frantzke, Helmut (2x)
Analyse statistique des coups candidats
Répartition par niveau Elo (% des parties)
Tranche Elo N parties 5…Nc6 5…Nf6 5…c5 5…Nd7
<1800 20 35% 20% 30%
1800-2200 344 40% 14% 22% 15%
2200-2600 1104 27% 30% 23% 7%
2600+ 46 11% 63% 15% 2%
Évolution par décennie (% des parties)
Décennie N parties 5…Nc6 5…Nf6 5…c5 5…Nd7
1960s 30 37% 43% 3% 7%
1970s 90 36% 28% 12% 11%
1980s 124 42% 25% 12% 8%
1990s 398 45% 15% 14% 12%
2000s 460 36% 26% 17% 10%
2010s 549 18% 33% 31% 8%
2020s 56 23% 36% 23% 9%
Tendances récentes (2010s → 2020s)
Coup 2010s 2020s Δ
5…Nc6 18% 23% ▲ +5.4%
5…Nf6 33% 36% ▲ +2.7%
5…c5 31% 23% ▼ -7.9%
5…Nd7 8% 9% ▲ +1.1%
Joueurs célèbres
Champions du monde dans cette position
Kramnik, Vladimir — 3 parties
Smyslov, Vladimir — 1 partie
Ding, Liren — 1 partie
Parties historiques
5…Nc6 — 32.4% (553 parties)
1960 — Incutto, Carlos vs Gadia, Olicio — 1/2-1/2 — Mar del Plata ARG
1965 — Litwinczuk, Walter vs Suttles, Duncan — 0-1 — Vancouver
1966 — Saidy, Anthony vs Suttles, Duncan — 1-0 — Seattle, WA USA
1966 — Stamler, C. vs Suttles, Duncan — 0-1 — San Francisco, CA USA
1966 — Aloni, Yoel vs Suttles, Duncan — 1-0 — Havana CUB
5…Nf6 — 26.3% (449 parties)
1960 — Golombek, Harry vs Alexander, Conol Hugh — 1/2-1/2 — Leicester
1961 — Kottnauer vs Adam Tan, Anas Tan — 1-0 — Beverwijk NED
1961 — Kottnauer, Cenek vs Tan Hoang Liong — 1-0 — Beverwijk NED
1965 — Szollosi, Akos vs Bilek, Istvan — 0-1 — CsB
1966 — Perez Perez, Francisco Jose vs Kleopas, Georgios — 1-0 — Havana CUB
5…c5 — 20.3% (346 parties)
1960 — Clarke, Peter H vs Portisch, Lajos — 1-0 — Leipzig GER
1971 — Toth, Bela vs Kluger, Gyula — 1-0 — HUN
1974 — Karim, Wahid vs Graa Tahar — 1/2-1/2 — Nice FRA
1975 — Ervin, Roy vs Barnes, Craig — 1-0 — Lone Pine, CA USA
1975 — Day, Lawrence A. vs Barnes, Craig — 0-1 — Lone Pine, CA USA
5…Nd7 — 9.5% (162 parties)
1966 — Cafferty, Bernard vs Brat, Vaclav Dr — 1-0 — corr ICCF
1968 — Wade, Robert G vs Hutchinson, Paul A — 1-0 — London ENG
1971 — Van den Berg, Carel B vs Huebner, Robert — 0-1 — ?
1971 — Van den Berg, Cees vs Huebner, Robert — 0-1 — Wijk aan Zee NED
1971 — Fatalibekova, Elena vs Blagojevic, Katarina — 0-1 — Ohrid MKD