Ambassadeurs : Kosteniuk, Alexandra (8x), Safarli, Elmir (7x), Domanov, Dmitry (6x), Nekhaev, Andrey Ivanovich (6x), Landa, Konstantin (4x), Dembo, Yelena (4x), Manduch, Milan Ing (4x), Gagliardi, Virgilio (4x)
5…Be7 — 30.9% (499 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Schubert, Steffen (7x), Pourkashiyan, Atousa (5x), Gelfand, Boris (4x), Lins, Thomas (4x), Bokros, Albert (4x), Korneev, Oleg (4x), Kosteniuk, Alexandra (3x), Bologan, Victor (3x)
5…Nc6 — 22.2% (359 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Deforel, Jorge Eduardo (10x), Romanishin, Oleg M (4x), Sorri, Kari Juhani (3x), Saric, Ante (3x), Cabrera Pino, Alexis Gianko (3x), Peltomaa, Jukka (3x), Herrera Rosero, Alex (3x), Bendaña Guerrero, Dr. Guy José (3x)
5…Bf5 — 3.8% (62 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Jonas William Henry (1x), Jacobsen, Julius Lee (1x), Lichtenhein, Theodore (1x), Montgomery, Hardman Philips (1x), Engels, Ludwig (1x), Perez Alcocer, Jose (1x), Kettner, Juergen (1x), Hertneck, Gerald (1x)
Analyse statistique des coups candidats
Répartition par niveau Elo (% des parties)
Tranche Elo
N parties
5…Nc5
5…Be7
5…Nc6
5…Bf5
<1800
56
20%
27%
16%
11%
1800-2200
560
37%
30%
22%
5%
2200-2600
659
46%
32%
20%
1%
2600+
60
33%
43%
23%
—
Évolution par décennie (% des parties)
Décennie
N parties
5…Nc5
5…Be7
5…Nc6
5…Bf5
1850s
1
—
—
—
—
1860s
2
—
50%
—
50%
1880s
3
67%
33%
—
—
1890s
7
29%
43%
—
14%
1900s
8
25%
38%
25%
—
1910s
1
—
100%
—
—
1920s
2
50%
50%
—
—
1930s
6
17%
50%
33%
—
1940s
3
—
33%
33%
—
1950s
11
45%
27%
18%
—
1960s
10
30%
30%
20%
10%
1970s
11
9%
55%
27%
—
1980s
38
34%
21%
37%
8%
1990s
112
31%
21%
36%
6%
2000s
474
32%
27%
31%
3%
2010s
789
42%
34%
16%
4%
2020s
139
53%
30%
12%
2%
Tendances récentes (2010s → 2020s)
Coup
2010s
2020s
Δ
5…Nc5
42%
53%
▲ +10.8%
5…Be7
34%
30%
▼ -3.9%
5…Nc6
16%
12%
▼ -4.1%
5…Bf5
4%
2%
▼ -1.8%
Joueurs célèbres
Champions du monde dans cette position
Karpov, Anatoly — 2 parties Carlsen, Magnus — 2 parties Ju, Wenjun — 2 parties Alekhine, Alexander — 1 partie Kramnik, Vladimir — 1 partie Gukesh D — 1 partie
Parties historiques
5…Nc5 — 38.3% (619 parties)
1889 — Gunsberg, Isidor vs Mason, James — 1/2-1/2 — New York, NY USA 1889 — Schiffers, Emanuel vs Mason, James — 1/2-1/2 — Breslau GER 1890 — Holzwarth, Joseph vs White, Max — 0-1 — Vienna AUT 1893 — Taubenhaus, Jean vs Delmar, Eugene — 0-1 — New York, NY USA 1900 — Simonson, Gustave vs Roething, Otto — 1-0 — New York, NY USA
5…Be7 — 30.9% (499 parties)
1860 — Kolisch, Ignac vs Fraser, George — 1/2-1/2 — Great Britain 1889 — Schiffers, Emanuel vs Alapin, Simon — 1-0 — Breslau GER 1890 — Mortimer, James vs Gossip, George — 1-0 — Manchester ENG 1896 — Dimer, Julius vs Barnes, Robert Henry — 0-1 — Eisenach 1898 — Behring vs Von Ehlert — 1-0 — ?
5…Nc6 — 22.2% (359 parties)
1902 — Alekhine, Alexander vs Petrov, S.E. — 1-0 — ? 1903 — Alekhine vs Petrov, S.E. — 0-1 — Correspondence 1937 — Duehrssen, Rudolf vs Michel, Paul — 0-1 — Bad Saarow 1938 — Bronstein, David I vs Zaslavsky, I. — 1-0 — Kiev UKR 1947 — Crowl, Frank Arthur vs Milner Barry, Philip — 0-1 — GB-Australia
5…Bf5 — 3.8% (62 parties)
1861 — Lichtenhein, Theodore vs Montgomery, Hardman Philips — 0-1 — Philadelphia, PA USA 1898 — Jonas William Henry vs Jacobsen, Julius Lee — 1/2-1/2 — Sydney AUS 1960 — Engels, Ludwig vs Perez Alcocer, Jose — 1-0 — Sao Paulo BRA 1980 — Jahn, Constanze vs Kube, Hannelore — 0-1 — Plauen 1986 — Kettner, Juergen vs Hertneck, Gerald — 0-1 — Duitsland tt
Carlsen, Magnus — 2 parties
Ju, Wenjun — 2 parties
Alekhine, Alexander — 1 partie
Kramnik, Vladimir — 1 partie
Gukesh D — 1 partie
1889 — Schiffers, Emanuel vs Mason, James — 1/2-1/2 — Breslau GER
1890 — Holzwarth, Joseph vs White, Max — 0-1 — Vienna AUT
1893 — Taubenhaus, Jean vs Delmar, Eugene — 0-1 — New York, NY USA
1900 — Simonson, Gustave vs Roething, Otto — 1-0 — New York, NY USA
1889 — Schiffers, Emanuel vs Alapin, Simon — 1-0 — Breslau GER
1890 — Mortimer, James vs Gossip, George — 1-0 — Manchester ENG
1896 — Dimer, Julius vs Barnes, Robert Henry — 0-1 — Eisenach
1898 — Behring vs Von Ehlert — 1-0 — ?
1903 — Alekhine vs Petrov, S.E. — 0-1 — Correspondence
1937 — Duehrssen, Rudolf vs Michel, Paul — 0-1 — Bad Saarow
1938 — Bronstein, David I vs Zaslavsky, I. — 1-0 — Kiev UKR
1947 — Crowl, Frank Arthur vs Milner Barry, Philip — 0-1 — GB-Australia
1898 — Jonas William Henry vs Jacobsen, Julius Lee — 1/2-1/2 — Sydney AUS
1960 — Engels, Ludwig vs Perez Alcocer, Jose — 1-0 — Sao Paulo BRA
1980 — Jahn, Constanze vs Kube, Hannelore — 0-1 — Plauen
1986 — Kettner, Juergen vs Hertneck, Gerald — 0-1 — Duitsland tt