C17b — Winawer, Advance (1937)
1.e4 e6 2.d4 d5 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.e5 c5 5.dxc5
Les coups candidats
5…Nc6 — 32.2% (198 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Gallagher, Joseph G. (9x), Hovhannisyan, Robert (3x), Cappello, Renato (2x), Moehring, Guenther (2x), Soltis, Andrew (2x), Sarapu, Ortvin (2x), Hirsch, Stefan (2x), Medvegy, Zoltan Dr. (2x)
5…Ne7 — 28.8% (177 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Zelcic, Robert (13x), Vitoux, Colomban (4x), Maier, Callie (4x), Maier, Christian (3x), Bokros, Albert (3x), Bukal, Vladimir Jr. (3x), Zufic, Miroslav (3x), Gallagher, Joseph G. (3x)
5…Qc7 — 15.3% (94 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Gallagher, Joseph G. (4x), Kiefer, Gerhard (4x), Myers, David G (2x), Mahling, Thomas (2x), Wohl, Aleksandar H (2x), Barthel, Ansgar (2x), Aditya Balu Jadhav (1x), Camarena, Joaquin (1x)
5…Bxc3+ — 9.1% (56 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Villing, Dieter (2x), Persitz, Raaphi (1x), Siemms, Ross E (1x), Fong, Lincoln (1x), Heldt, Thomas Jr (1x), Goldenov, Boris P (1x), Nekrasova, Elena (1x), Bhimani, Ratilal Zinabhai (1x)
Analyse statistique des coups candidats
Répartition par niveau Elo (% des parties)
Tranche Elo N parties 5…Nc6 5…Ne7 5…Qc7 5…Bxc3+
<1800 36 19% 8% 19% 8%
1800-2200 233 31% 23% 17% 14%
2200-2600 255 38% 40% 13% 3%
2600+ 5 — 100% — —
Évolution par décennie (% des parties)
Décennie N parties 5…Nc6 5…Ne7 5…Qc7 5…Bxc3+
1950s 10 30% — 20% 30%
1960s 12 42% 42% 17% —
1970s 18 33% 17% 33% 11%
1980s 46 28% 35% 22% 7%
1990s 94 39% 19% 15% 9%
2000s 234 33% 30% 15% 6%
2010s 176 29% 31% 12% 13%
2020s 24 25% 38% 12% 8%
Tendances récentes (2010s → 2020s)
Coup 2010s 2020s Δ
5…Nc6 29% 25% ▼ -4.0%
5…Ne7 31% 38% ▲ +6.2%
5…Qc7 12% 12% ▲ +0.6%
5…Bxc3+ 13% 8% ▼ -4.7%
Parties historiques
5…Nc6 — 32.2% (198 parties)
1952 — Estrin, Yakov vs Zagorovsky, Vladimir — 0-1 — Moscow RUS
1953 — Goldenov vs Nekrasov, Aleksander — 1-0 — ?
1958 — Jezek, Stanislav vs Platz, Hans — 1-0 — CSR-DDR Prague CZE
1964 — Aditya Balu Jadhav vs Cappello, Renato — 1/2-1/2 — Lenzerheide-Clare Be
1964 — Moehring, Guenther vs Brauer, Christian — 1-0 — Rabenberg
5…Ne7 — 28.8% (177 parties)
1961 — Raetsch, Heinz vs Fuchs, Reinhart — 1/2-1/2 — GDR-ch Premnitz GER
1963 — Zinser, Sylvain vs Ackermann, Herbert — 1-0 — Eberhardt Wilhelm Cup prel 63
1964 — Moehring, Guenther vs Golz, Werner — 1-0 — Magdeburg GER
1964 — Orev, Petar vs Kadrev, Zdravko Minchev — 0-1 — Sofia BUL
1968 — Keller, Dieter vs Sigurjonsson, Gudmundur — 0-1 — Lugano olm
5…Qc7 — 15.3% (94 parties)
1955 — Durgo, Ivan vs Zaradic, Ante — 1-0 — Zagreb CRO
1958 — Persitz, Raaphi vs Blumenfeld, Rudy — 1-0 — Haifa/Tel Aviv
1960 — Szabo, Laszlo vs Portisch, Lajos — 1/2-1/2 — Budapest HUN
1964 — Aditya Balu Jadhav vs Camarena, Joaquin — 1-0 — Tel Aviv ISR
1973 — Ljubojevic, Ljubomir vs Hug, Werner — 1-0 — Petropolis izt
5…Bxc3+ — 9.1% (56 parties)
1953 — Persitz, Raaphi vs Siemms, Ross E — 0-1 — Copenhagen DEN
1953 — Goldenov, Boris P vs Nekrasova, Elena — 1-0 — Minsk BLR
1957 — Fong, Lincoln vs Heldt, Thomas Jr — 0-1 — San Francisco, CA USA
1976 — Velimirovic, Dragoljub vs Jancev, Lazo — 1-0 — Skopje MKD
1978 — Rahmatian, Amir Mahdi vs Monro, Kent — 0-1 — Vancouver BC CAN