Ambassadeurs : Clarke, Paul R H (3x), Cylwik, Zbigniew (2x), Bertok, Mario Jr. (2x), Doda, Zbigniew (2x), Markowski, Piotr (2x), Morozkov, Artemiy (1x), Ilyin Zhenevsky, Alexander (1x), Darga, Klaus (1x)
5…a6 — 17.7% (58 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Avner, Uri (1x), Lederman, Leon (1x), Csom, Istvan (1x), Karlsson, Lars 1937 (1x), Kataev, Simcho (1x), Kaspi, Alexander (1x), Bors, Tamas (1x), Hardicsay, Peter (1x)
5…Bb4+ — 12.8% (42 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Filip, Marius Liviu (1x), Stahlberg, Gideon (1x), Simkin, Y (1x), Yuhtman, Jacov (1x), Cebalo, Miso (1x), Boskovic, Milorad (1x), Petrosian, Tigran A. (1x), Korchnoi, Viktor (1x)
5…Be7 — 12.2% (40 parties)
Ambassadeurs : Segal, Alexandru Sorin (2x), Browne, Walter Shawn (2x), Priehoda, Vitezslav (2x), Kottnauer, Cenek (1x), Zíta, František (1x), Filip, Marius Liviu (1x), Pachman, Ludek (1x), Taimanov, Mark (1x)
Analyse statistique des coups candidats
Répartition par niveau Elo (% des parties)
Tranche Elo
N parties
5…Nc6
5…a6
5…Bb4+
5…Be7
<1800
6
33%
17%
17%
—
1800-2200
100
39%
18%
9%
12%
2200-2600
121
40%
26%
13%
12%
2600+
2
50%
50%
—
—
Évolution par décennie (% des parties)
Décennie
N parties
5…Nc6
5…a6
5…Bb4+
5…Be7
1930s
1
100%
—
—
—
1940s
1
—
—
—
100%
1950s
6
67%
—
17%
17%
1960s
21
71%
—
14%
5%
1970s
32
66%
3%
9%
22%
1980s
9
22%
11%
22%
22%
1990s
40
40%
20%
20%
8%
2000s
94
38%
23%
9%
14%
2010s
100
39%
21%
14%
11%
2020s
23
35%
22%
13%
4%
Tendances récentes (2010s → 2020s)
Coup
2010s
2020s
Δ
5…Nc6
39%
35%
▼ -4.2%
5…a6
21%
22%
▲ +0.7%
5…Bb4+
14%
13%
▼ -1.0%
5…Be7
11%
4%
▼ -6.7%
Joueurs célèbres
Champions du monde dans cette position
Smyslov, Vladimir — 1 partie Tal, Mikhail — 1 partie Karpov, Anatoly — 1 partie
Parties historiques
5…Nc6 — 43.4% (142 parties)
1931 — Morozkov, Artemiy vs Ilyin Zhenevsky, Alexander — 0-1 — Moscow RUS 1954 — Hoenlinger, Baldur vs Unzicker, Wolfgang — 0-1 — Duisburg/Hamborn 1954 — Bobekov, Radko vs Keres, Paul — 0-1 — Amsterdam NED 1957 — Troger, Emma vs Schuster, Ailleann — 1-0 — Bad Neuenahr GER 1959 — Simagin, Vladimir vs Khodos, German — 0-1 — Leningrad RUS
5…a6 — 17.7% (58 parties)
1973 — Avner, Uri vs Lederman, Leon — 1-0 — Netanya ISR 1983 — Csom, Istvan vs Karlsson, Lars 1937 — 1/2-1/2 — Copenhagen DEN 1991 — Gayet, Philippe vs Giffard, Nicolas — 0-1 — Frankrijk tt 1993 — Madina Yadarola, Martin A vs Szmetan, Jorge — 1/2-1/2 — Buenos Aires ARG 1994 — Kataev, Simcho vs Kaspi, Alexander — 0-1 — Tel Aviv ISR
5…Bb4+ — 12.8% (42 parties)
1954 — Filip, Marius Liviu vs Stahlberg, Gideon — 1/2-1/2 — Bucharest ROU 1966 — Simkin, Y vs Yuhtman, Jacov — 1-0 — ? 1969 — Cebalo, Miso vs Boskovic, Milorad — 1-0 — Pula CRO 1969 — Petrosian, Tigran A. vs Korchnoi, Viktor — 1/2-1/2 — Palma de Majorca ESP 1972 — Ek, Hans vs Jansson, Borje — 1/2-1/2 — Sweden
5…Be7 — 12.2% (40 parties)
1943 — Kottnauer, Cenek vs Zíta, František — 1-0 — Zlin CZE 1954 — Filip, Marius Liviu vs Pachman, Ludek — 1/2-1/2 — Czechoslovakia 1962 — Taimanov, Mark vs Matanovic, Aleksandar — 1-0 — Lvov UKR 1972 — Martinovsky, Eugene vs Browne, Walter Shawn — 1-0 — Statham Masters Open 1972 — Pomar Salamanca, Arturo vs Browne, Walter Shawn — 0-1 — Malaga ESP
Tal, Mikhail — 1 partie
Karpov, Anatoly — 1 partie
1954 — Hoenlinger, Baldur vs Unzicker, Wolfgang — 0-1 — Duisburg/Hamborn
1954 — Bobekov, Radko vs Keres, Paul — 0-1 — Amsterdam NED
1957 — Troger, Emma vs Schuster, Ailleann — 1-0 — Bad Neuenahr GER
1959 — Simagin, Vladimir vs Khodos, German — 0-1 — Leningrad RUS
1983 — Csom, Istvan vs Karlsson, Lars 1937 — 1/2-1/2 — Copenhagen DEN
1991 — Gayet, Philippe vs Giffard, Nicolas — 0-1 — Frankrijk tt
1993 — Madina Yadarola, Martin A vs Szmetan, Jorge — 1/2-1/2 — Buenos Aires ARG
1994 — Kataev, Simcho vs Kaspi, Alexander — 0-1 — Tel Aviv ISR
1966 — Simkin, Y vs Yuhtman, Jacov — 1-0 — ?
1969 — Cebalo, Miso vs Boskovic, Milorad — 1-0 — Pula CRO
1969 — Petrosian, Tigran A. vs Korchnoi, Viktor — 1/2-1/2 — Palma de Majorca ESP
1972 — Ek, Hans vs Jansson, Borje — 1/2-1/2 — Sweden
1954 — Filip, Marius Liviu vs Pachman, Ludek — 1/2-1/2 — Czechoslovakia
1962 — Taimanov, Mark vs Matanovic, Aleksandar — 1-0 — Lvov UKR
1972 — Martinovsky, Eugene vs Browne, Walter Shawn — 1-0 — Statham Masters Open
1972 — Pomar Salamanca, Arturo vs Browne, Walter Shawn — 0-1 — Malaga ESP